| # | Title | Rating | Length |
|---|
| C1 | Good King Joy- recording engineer and mixer:
- Dave Whittman
- additional engineer:
- Dominick Barbera , Robert Kinkel, John Seymour and Steve Sola
- assistant engineer:
- Ben Arrindell , James Carabello and Matt Thrasher
- co-producer:
- Robert Kinkel
- producer:
- Paul O’Neill
- phonographic copyright (℗) by:
- Atlantic Recording Corporation (in 1996) and WEA International Inc. (in 1996)
- recorded at:
- Sound Tracks in New York, New York, United States and Studio 900 in New York, New York, United States
- mixed at:
- Sound Tracks in New York, New York, United States
- recording of:
- Good King Joy
- lyricist:
- Paul O’Neill
- composer:
- Robert Kinkel and Paul O’Neill
- publisher:
- Paul O’Neill Publishing (from 1997 to present), Robert Steller Publishing (from 1997 to present) and Warner–Tamerlane Publishing Corp. (from 1997 to present)
- is based on:
- Good King Wenceslas
- is based on:
- Joy to the World
| 5 | ?:?? |
| C2 | Ornament | 4.5 | ?:?? |
| C3 | The First Noel (instrumental) | 5 | ?:?? |
| C4 | Old City Bar | 5 | ?:?? |
| D1 | Promises to Keep- recording engineer and mixer:
- Dave Whittman
- additional engineer:
- Dominick Barbera , Robert Kinkel, John Seymour and Steve Sola
- assistant engineer:
- Ben Arrindell , James Carabello and Matt Thrasher
- co-producer:
- Robert Kinkel
- producer:
- Paul O’Neill
- phonographic copyright (℗) by:
- Atlantic Recording Corporation (in 1996) and WEA International Inc. (in 1996)
- recorded at:
- Sound Tracks in New York, New York, United States and Studio 900 in New York, New York, United States
- mixed at:
- Sound Tracks in New York, New York, United States
- recording of:
- Promises to Keep
- lyricist:
- Paul O’Neill
- composer:
- Robert Kinkel and Paul O’Neill
- publisher:
- Paul O’Neill Publishing (from 1997 to present), Robert Steller Publishing (from 1997 to present) and Warner–Tamerlane Publishing Corp. (from 1997 to present)
| 5 | ?:?? |
| D2 | This Christmas Day- recording engineer and mixer:
- Dave Whittman
- additional engineer:
- Dominick Barbera , Robert Kinkel, John Seymour and Steve Sola
- assistant engineer:
- Ben Arrindell , James Carabello and Matt Thrasher
- co-producer:
- Robert Kinkel
- producer:
- Paul O’Neill
- phonographic copyright (℗) by:
- Atlantic Recording Corporation (in 1996) and WEA International Inc. (in 1996)
- recorded at:
- Sound Tracks in New York, New York, United States and Studio 900 in New York, New York, United States
- mixed at:
- Sound Tracks in New York, New York, United States
- recording of:
- This Christmas Day
- lyricist:
- Paul O’Neill
- composer:
- Paul O’Neill and Jon Oliva
- publisher:
- John Oliva Pub Designee (from 1997 to ????), Paul O’Neill Publishing (from 1997 to present), Warner–Tamerlane Publishing Corp. (from 1997 to present) and WB Music Corp. (from 1997 to present)
| 5 | ?:?? |
| D3 | An Angel Returned | 4 | ?:?? |
| D4 | O’ Holy Night | 5 | ?:?? |
| D5 | God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen- recording engineer and mixer:
- Dave Whittman
- additional engineer:
- Dominick Barbera , Robert Kinkel, John Seymour and Steve Sola
- assistant engineer:
- Ben Arrindell , James Carabello and Matt Thrasher
- co-producer:
- Robert Kinkel
- producer:
- Paul O’Neill
- phonographic copyright (℗) by:
- Atlantic Recording Corporation (in 1996) and WEA International Inc. (in 1996)
- recorded at:
- Sound Tracks in New York, New York, United States and Studio 900 in New York, New York, United States
- mixed at:
- Sound Tracks in New York, New York, United States
- recording of:
- God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen
- composer:
- [traditional]
- arranger:
- Paul O’Neill
- publisher:
- Paul O’Neill Publishing and Warner–Tamerlane Publishing Corp.
- arrangement of:
- God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen
| 5 | ?:?? |